price and product comparisons power shopper book zone

 
Books & Buyer's Guides

Information Hubs



Other Product Information

 

Site Supporters

Apple iPhone Prices At ...
Apple Store
Canada Apple Store
Cingular Wireless
iPhone InfoZone

Going Shopping?

Using the links above supports MacReviewZone!


send this page

Send to a friend



News Feed
Feed Information

Mailing list ... List information.


Latest Discussion Threads

MacReviewZone Gift Shop


The MacComparisonZone: 14 Inch G4/1.2GHz iBook vs 12 Inch G4/1.33GHz PowerBook - What Are The Performance, Feature And Price Differences - Updated

Specially prepared for David ... Request your own Custom Comparison

Introduction

Updated: 9/13/04

This Buyer's Guide compares the 14 inch G4/1.2GHz iBook, which has the Combo optical drive, to the 12 Inch G4/1.33GHz PowerBook, which also has the Combo Drive.

The 1.2GHz iBook was released in April of 2004. It is the high-end model of a family of three, which includes a 1.0 GHz 14 inch machine, and a 1GHz 12 inch iBook.

The current 1.33GHz 12 inch PowerBook, was also released in April, 2004. It is the low-end model of a family of four, which includes a 1.5GHz 17 inch PowerBook, and 1.5GHz & 1.33GHz, 15 inch machines.

Major Technological Differences:

Processor Speed
Screen Size
Weight
Price Difference: $100
Bus Speed
RAM Type
Graphics Card And Video Memory Amount
Audio In
BlueTooth
External Video Support
Audio System

Below you will find specifications and features, performance, and price comparisons. We also provide further links where you can do additional research, should you so wish.

Give us your feedback. Tell your friends about our service!


Specifications & Features

Model/Mhz

iBook G4/1.2GHz (14")
(#M9165LL/A )


L2 Cache: 512K @ 1.2GHz
L3 Cache: None
Release Date: April, 2004

5.9 pounds (2.7 kg)

Battery Life: 61-watt 6 Hours

PowerBook G4/1.33GHz (12")
(#M9183LL/A - Combo Drive)
(#M9184LL/A - SuperDrive)

L2 Cache: 512K @ 1.33GHz
L3 Cache: None
Release Date: April, 2004

4.6 pounds (2.1 kg)

Battery Life: 50-watt 5 Hours

Price Information

MSRP: $1499

Apple Store
DealZone

MSRP: $1,599 - Combo Drive
MSRP: $1,799 - SuperDrive
Apple Store
DealZone

Bus Speed
(Mhz)

133 MHz
167 MHz

RAM
(MAX)

256 MB
PC2100 (266MHz)
(1.25GB)
256MB
PC2700 (333MHz) DDR SDRAM
(1.25 GB max)

Graphics Support

ATI Mobility Radeon 9200
32MB of DDR SDRAM
4x AGP
NVIDIA GeForce FX Go5200
64MB of DDR SDRAM
4x AGP

Expansion
Slots

AirPort Extreme (54 Mbps) slot

AirPort Extreme (54 Mbps) slot

Hard Drive

60GB ATA/100
4200 rpm
60 GB Ultra ATA/100
4200rpm

Optical Drive

Combination Drive (slot loading)
Writes CD-R at 24x
Writes CD-RW at 16x
Reads DVD-ROM at 8x
Reads CD-ROM at 24x

Combination drive (slot loading)
CD R - 24x
CD-RW write - 16x
DVD read - 8x
CD read - 24x
or
"SuperDrive" (slot loading)
CD-R write - 16x
CD-RW write - 8x
DVD read - 8x
CD read - 24x
DVD write 4x

Connectivity & Communication

56k modem

Installed 54-Mbps AirPort Extreme Card (based on 802.11g standard; 802.11b Wi-Fi certified)

10/100 BT Ethernet

2 USB 2.0 Ports (480 Mbps)
1 FireWire Port (400 Mbps)

Audio out

Optional Bluetooth 1.1

56k modem

Installed 54-Mbps AirPort Extreme Card (based on 802.11g standard; 802.11b Wi-Fi certified)

10/100 BT Ethernet

2 USB 2.0 Ports (480 Mbps)
1 FireWire Port (400 Mbps)

Audio in & out

Bluetooth 1.1 built in

Video

14.1-inch (diagonal) TFT XGA active-matrix
1024x768 resolutions with millions of colors








VGA video output for video mirroring on an external display or projector (24-bit color) with included Apple VGA Display Adapter

S-video and composite video output to TV or projector (requires Apple Video Adapter, sold separately)

Video mirroring only

12.1-inch (diagonal) TFT
1024 x 768

2048 x 1536 support on external display

Mini-DVI port

DVI output using included mini-DVI to DVI adapter

ADC output using optional Apple DVI to ADC Adapter

VGA output using included mini-DVI to VGA adapter

S-video and composite video output using mini-DVI to video adapter (sold separately)


Dual display and video mirroring: Simultaneously supports up to 1024 by 768 pixels on the built-in display and up to 2048 by 1536 pixels on an external display, both at millions of color

Specification Notes

Optional SuperDrive instead of Combo Drive

Has third speaker for midrange
Audio line in

Performance
Machine
iBook G4/1.2GHz (14")
(#M9165LL/A )
PowerBook G4/1.33GHz (#M9183LL/A - Combo Drive)
Processor
108 Points
121 Points- - 12% Faster
Processor Multitasking
294.81 seconds
252.88 seconds- - 16% Faster
Processor G4 Tuned
40.09 seconds
36.94 seconds- - 9% Faster
Graphics (Card)
306 Points
505 Points - - 65% Faster
Graphics (Processor)
127 Points
144 Points - - 13% Faster
Graphics Gaming
(Graphics Card)
10.8 frames per second
14.9 frames per second - - 38% Faster
Graphics Gaming
(Processor)
23.5 frames per second
26.5 frames per second - - 13% Faster
Drive Muti-Files
204.77 seconds
216.74 seconds - - 6% Slower
Drive Single File
126.89 seconds
137.11 seconds - - 8% Slower
Burn CD
127.01 seconds
104.20 seconds - - 22% Faster
General - Interface
41.16 seconds
21.59 seconds - - 91% Faster
iTunes Encode (CD)
159.48 seconds
160.99 seconds - - 1% Slower
QuickTime Encode
38.88 seconds
33.11 seconds - - 17% Faster
iMovie Render
170.88 seconds
134.62 seconds - - 27% Faster
iDVD Import
87.11 seconds
71.23 seconds - - 22% Faster
Photoshop (Workflow)
47.35 seconds
44.97 seconds - - 5% Faster
Photoshop (Filters)
115.49 seconds
107.13 seconds - - 8% Faster
StuffIt Expand
64.81 seconds
61.29 seconds - - 6% Faster
MS Word
84.16. seconds
68.06 seconds - - 24% Faster
MS Excel
49.18. seconds
43.81 seconds - - 12% Faster
Battery Life
213 Minutes
148 Minutes- - 44% Less Time
Notes

The PowerBook is 9 to 16 percent faster than the iBook, in raw processing ability. The clock speed difference between the two machines is about 11%.

The drive in this iBook performed much better than the one we tested in the 12 inch iBook.

The graphics card in the PowerBook is clearly superior to the one installed in the iBook. The same graphics card is installed in all the current iBooks. We think that the dramatic disparity between the two laptops in the General Interface test, must be down to the graphics card. We found that all the iBooks performed comparatively poorly in this test (though they turned in roughly the same score as each other). This test opens and closes 1,000 windows as fast as possible.

Again, you will get much more time out of the iBook battery, than the PowerBook battery.

Airport reception is also better in the iBook.

Processor performance based on CineBench 2003

Processor G4 Tuned Test based on AltiVec Fractal program

Graphics (Card) Test is based on CineBench 2003. In this type of image rendering, the graphics card takes the lead

Graphics (Processor) Test is based on CineBench 2003. In this type of image rendering, the processor takes the lead

Graphics Gaming (Card) Test is based on the game 4x4 EVO2 .. a racing game. All settings are at highest quality. This game is more graphics card dependent

Graphics Gaming (Processor) Test is based on the game Giants.. All settings are at highest quality. This game is more processor dependent ... will also make used of dual processors if present

The 'General Interface' test is based on Let1kWindowsBloom, which is freely available.

The Photoshop (Workflow) score is based on the BareFeats Photoshop Action Script, which you can download and run on your own machine, if you have Photoshop.

Battery Life was tested by playing a DVD movie on the fully charged machine until it was completely drained.

Have questions about the performance of these machines?
For more detailed performance results see this page

Links To Further Information
Machine
iBook G4/1.2GHz (14")
(#M9165LL/A )
PowerBook G4/1.33GHz (12")
Reviews

MacComparisonZone: 14 Inch G4/1.2 Gz iBook vs 15 Inch G4/1.33 GHz PowerBook

MacComparisonZone: 14 Inch G4/1.2 Gz iBook vs 15 Inch G4/1.33 GHz PowerBook vs 15 Inch G4/1.5GHz PowerBook

ComparisonZone: 12 Inch 1GHz iBook vs 14 Inch 1.2GHz iBook

ComputerWorld

MacComparisonZone: 12 Inch G4/1.0GHz PowerBook vs 12 Inch G4/1.0GHz iBook vs 12 Inch G4/1.33GHz PowerBook

MacComparisonZone: 12 Inch G4/1.0GHz iBook vs 12 Inch G4/1.33GHz PowerBook

MacComparisonZone: 15 Inch CRT G3/400MHz iMac DV vs 12 Inch G4/1.33GHz PowerBook

G4/450 MHz Cube vs 12 Inch G4/1.33 GHz PowerBook

12 Inch G4/1.33 GHz PowerBook vs 15 Inch G4/1.5 GHz PowerBook

MacComparisonZone: 15 Inch G4/1.25 GHz PowerBook vs 12 Inch G4/1.33 GHz PowerBook

MacComparisonZone: 12 Inch G4/867 MHz PowerBook vs 12 Inch G4/1.33 GHz PowerBook

MacComparisonZone: 12 Inch G4/867 MHz PowerBook vs 12 Inch G4/1 GHz iBook vs 12 Inch G4/1.33 GHz PowerBook

SpeedZone: New PowerBooks How Fast Are They? - 16 Tests On Current Portables

ComputerWorld
Macworld
ComputerWorld

Links to additional information

Additional Resources:
PowerBook Info Zone
PowerBook Performance
PowerBook Performance vs Others
PowerBook Buyer's Guide
Closeout - Refurbished PowerBooks
Apple's PowerBook Web Pages
PowerBook Specs & Features
PowerBook Discussion Forum

Price & Bundle Comparisons

Note

We receive a small commission on computers purchased using the links below. Though this adds no cost to your purchase price, it does help us defray the cost of running MacReviewZone and MacSpeedZone. Your support is appreciated! As always check your tax status at these merchants so that you don't get a nasty shock at checkout time.

For Latest up-to-date prices check the online Buyer's Guides


iBook G4/1.2 GHz 14.1" Screen, Combination Drive #M9419LL/A
Store

Apple Store

Price & Shipping*

$1,499 .... Education Discount Price: $1,399
Free shipping

Sales Tax

All states with sales tax.

Deals & Bundles

available - Available

unknown/delay - Unknown/Delay

unavailable - Unavailable

Apple Promotions and:

unavailable Base machine (1-3 days)
unavailable HP Photosmart 7660 inkjet photo printer, $30 after mail-in rebate ($129 up front)
unavailable HP DeskJet 5850 Wireless Inkjet Printer, $50 after mail-in rebate ($149 up front)
unavailable HP PSC 2410 Multifunction Printer, $200 after mail-in rebate ($299 up front)
delay PSC 2175 all-in-one, $80 after rebate ($179 up front)
delay DeskJet 5740 inkjet printer, free after rebate ($99 up front)

 
Store

ClubMac Best buy

Price & Shipping*

$1,494
Free shipping after mail-in rebate

Sales Tax

CA, TN, WI

Deals & Bundles

available - Available

unknown/delay - Unknown/Delay

unavailable - Unavailable

Apple Promotions and any/all of the following:

available Base Machine
available Yamakawa DVD player, free after mail-in rebate ($40 up front)
available Final Cut Express for $99
unavailable 512 MB RAM, free after rebate, $40 install
available "You Control" software for $10 (a $50 value)
available Free case after mail-in rebate ($30 up front)
available Epson Stylus C84 printer, free after mail-in rebate ($99 up front)
available HP deskjet 6127, $99 discount via mail-in rebate ($250 up front)
available Epson Stylus Photo RX600, $129 discount via mail-in rebates ($349 up front)
available Epson CX6400 multi-function printer, $109 discount via mail-in rebates ($199 up front)
available Epson Stylus Photo R800, $50 discount via mail-in rebate ($399 up front)
available Epson Stylus Photo RX500, $50 discount via mail-in rebate ($249 up front)

 
Store

MacConnection

Price & Shipping*

$1,494
$13 shipping

Sales Tax

MA, NC, OH, TN

Deals & Bundles

available - Available

unknown/delay - Unknown/Delay

unavailable - Unavailable

unavailable Base Machine
unavailable 512 MB RAM, free after mail-in rebate ($40 install fee)
available Epson C84 printer, free after mail-in rebates ($100 up front)
availableLowepro USA Tropolis 1200, free after mail-in rebate ($70 up front)

 
Store

MacMall Best buy

Price & Shipping*

$1,494
Free shipping asfter mail-in rebate

Sales Tax

CA, TN, WI

Deals & Bundles

available - Available

unknown/delay - Unknown/Delay

unavailable - Unavailable

Apple Promotions and any/all of the following:

available Base Machine
available Yamakawa DVD player, free after mail-in rebate ($40 up front)
available Final Cut Express for $99
unavailable 512 MB RAM, free after rebate, $40 install
available "You Control" software for $10 (a $50 value)
available Free case after mail-in rebate ($30 up front)
available Epson Stylus C84 printer, free after mail-in rebate ($99 up front)
available HP deskjet 6127, $99 discount via mail-in rebate ($250 up front)
available Epson Stylus Photo RX600, $129 discount via mail-in rebates ($349 up front)
available Epson CX6400 multi-function printer, $109 discount via mail-in rebates ($199 up front)
available Epson Stylus Photo R800, $50 discount via mail-in rebate ($399 up front)
available Epson Stylus Photo RX500, $50 discount via mail-in rebate ($249 up front)

 
Store

MacZone

Price & Shipping*

$1,495
Free shipping for a "limited time"

Sales Tax

CA, IL, MO, NV, OH, TN, WA

Deals & Bundles

available - Available

unknown/delay - Unknown/Delay

unavailable - Unavailable

Apple Promotions and:

Site offline at time of update. Data below is from July 8th update.

available Base Machine
available 512MB RAM, free after mail-in rebate ($40 installation fee)

 
Store PowerMax
Price & Shipping*

$1,488
$22 shipping charge

Sales Tax

None

Deals & Bundles

available - Available

unknown - Unknown/Delay

unavailable - Unavailable

Apple Promotions and any/all of the following:

Base Machine
Free ScreensavRz laptop pad/screen protector
Free USB "Mega Memory" watch after mail-in rebate ($50 up front)
Final Cut Express 2.0 for $99
HP DeskJet 5150 inkjet printer, free after rebate ($100 up front)

PowerMax does not provide availability information online...


12.1" PowerBook G4/1.33GHz Combo Drive #M9183LL/A
Store

Apple Store

Price & Shipping*

$1,599 ... Education Discount Price: $1,399
Free Shipping

Sales Tax

All states with sales tax.

Deals & Bundles

available - Available

unknown - Unknown/Delay

unavailable - Unavailable

Apple Promotions and:

available Base Machine
unavailable HP Photosmart 7660 inkjet photo printer, $30 after mail-in rebate ($129 up front)
unavailable HP DeskJet 5850 Wireless Inkjet Printer, $50 after mail-in rebate ($149 up front)
unavailable HP PSC 2410 Multifunction Printer, $200 after mail-in rebate ($299 up front)
delay PSC 2175 all-in-one, $80 after rebate ($179 up front)
delay DeskJet 5740 inkjet printer, free after rebate ($99 up front)

 
Store

ClubMac

Price & Shipping*

$1,594
Free shipping after mail-in rebate

Sales Tax

CA, TN, WI

Deals & Bundles

available - Available

unknown - Unknown/Delay

unavailable - Unavailable