price and product comparisons power shopper book zone
Books & Buyer's Guides

Books
Using iLife ... Books
Using iWork ... Books
Using The iPod ... Books
All Books On Apple Products ...

Information Hubs




Other Product Information


Site Supporters

send this page

Send to a friend

News Feed

Mailing list ...List information...


MacReviewZone Gift Shop





The MacComparisonZone: Power Mac Dual G4/1 GHz vs PowerMac Dual G5/1.6 GHz - What Are The Performance, Feature And Price Differences

Specially prepared for Robert ... Request your own Custom Comparison

Introduction

10/13/04

This Buyer's Guide compares the PowerMac Dual G4/1 GHz (Quicksliver), which has the SuperDrive optical drive, to the PowerMac Dual G5/1.6 GHz, which also has a SuperDrive.

The PowerMac Dual G4/1 GHz (Quicksliver) was released in January, 2002. It was the high-end model of a family of three, which included a single processor G4/800 MHz machine at the low-end, and a single G4/933 MHz Tower in the middle.

The 1.6GHz G5 Tower, was released 19 months later, in June, 2003. It was the low-end model of a family of three, which included a Dual 2.0 GHz machine at the high-end and a Single Processor 1.8GHz Tower in the middle. In November, 2003, the single processor 1.8GHz Tower was dropped in favor of a dual processor machine running at the same clock-speed.

Major Technological Differences:

Processor Number/Speed/Type
Cache Size/Speed/Types
Bus Speed
Price Difference: $100
RAM Type/Amount/Maximum
Graphics Card/Slot
Expansion Slots
Hard Drive Type
Optical Drive Speed
Airport Speed
USB Port Speed/Number
FireWire Port Speed/Number
Audio In/Out Options
Wireless Communication
External Video Support
Weight

Below you will find specifications and features, performance, and price comparisons. We also provide further links where you can do additional research, should you so wish.

Give us your feedback. Tell your friends about our service!


Specifications & Features

Model/Mhz

Power Mac G4/1 GHz
(#M8667LL/A )
Dual Processor
256K L2 Cache @ 1 GHz (per processor)
2 MB L3 Cache (per processor)
Release Date: January, 2002

Power Mac G5/1.6 GHz
(#M9020LL/A )
Single Processor
L2 Cache: 512K @ 1.6 GHz
L3 Cache: None
Release Date: June, 2003

Price Information

MSRP: $2,999
Current Price: $1,200
DealZone

MSRP: $1,799
Current Price: $1,300
DealZone

Bus Speed
(Mhz)

133 MHz
800 MHZ Frontside bus

RAM
(MAX)

512 MB (1GB as tested)
PC133 SDRAM
( 1.5 GB max)

256MB (1.25GB as tested)
PC2700 333MHz DDR SDRAM
( 4 GB max)

Graphics Support

NVIDIA GeForce4 MX with
64MB of DDR SDRAM
AGP 4X graphics slot

NVIDIA GeForce FX 5200 Ultra
64MB DDR SDRAM
AGP Pro 8X

Expansion
Slots

Three 3.5-inch hard drive bays (one filled)
One optical drive bay (one filled)
Four 64-bit, 33MHz PCI
One AGP 4X (filled)
AirPort Slot

Two hard drive bays (one filled)
One optical drive bay (filled)
Three open full-length 33MHz, 64-bit PCI slots
One AGP Pro 8X (filled)
AirPort Extreme Slot

Hard Drive

80 GB Ultra ATA
7200 rpm
80GB Serial ATA
7200 rpm

Optical Drive

Tray loading SuperDrive
(DVD-R/CD-RW)
Writes DVD-R at 2x
Reads DVDs at 6x
Writes CD-R at 8x
Writes CD-RW at 4x
Reads CDs at 32x

Tray loading SuperDrive
(DVD-R/CD-RW)
Writes DVD-R at 4x
Reads DVDs at 8x
Writes CD-R at 16x
Writes CD-RW at 10x
Reads CDs at 32x

Connectivity & Communication

56k modem

Optional 11-Mbps AirPort Card
(802.11b)

10/100/1000BaseT

4 USB 1 Ports (12 Mbps)
2 FireWire Port (400 Mbps)


Analog Stereo out minijack

56k V.92 modem

Optional 54-Mbps AirPort Extreme Card (based on 802.11g standard; 802.11b Wi-Fi certified)

10/100/1000 BT Ethernet

3 USB 2.0 Ports (480 Mbps)
2 FireWire Port (400 Mbps)
1 FireWire 800 Port

Optical digital audio in and out Toslink connectors

Analog Stereo audio in and out minijacks

Optional Bluetooth 1.1 module and antenna

Video

Support for digital resolutions up to 1920 by 1200 pixels

ADC and VGA connectors



Dual display support for extended desktop and video mirroring modes

Support for digital resolutions up to 1920 by 1200 pixels

ADC and DVI connectors

DVI to VGA adapter included

Dual display support for extended desktop and video mirroring modes

Specification Notes

Weight:30 pounds (13.6 kg)

Weight: 39.2 pounds (17.8 kilos)

Performance
Machine
Power Mac Dual G4/1 GHz
(#M8667LL/A )
Power Mac G5/1.6 GHz
(#M9020LL/A )
Processor
95 Points
166 Points- - 75% Faster
Processor (Dual)
172 Points
166 Points- - 4% Slower
Processor Multitasking
147.77 seconds
184.72seconds - - 26% Slower
Processor G4 Tuned
26.56 seconds
46.26 seconds - - 74% Slower
Graphics (Card)
174 Points
838 Points - - 382% Faster
Graphics (Processor)
119 Points
198 Points - - 66% Faster
Graphics Gaming
(Graphics Card)
20 frames per second
28 frames per second - - 40% Faster
Graphics Gaming
(Processor)
44 frames per second
34 frames per second - - 29% Slower
Drive Multi-Files
179.81 seconds
146.64 seconds - - 23% Faster
Drive Single File
94.61 seconds
67.04 seconds - - 41% Faster
Burn CD
112.09 seconds
73.82 seconds - - 52% Faster
General - Interface
20.01seconds
27.20 seconds - - 36% Slower
iTunes Encode (CD)
76.92 seconds
93.16 seconds - - 21% Slower
QuickTime Encode
124.81 seconds
112.37 seconds - - 11% Faster
iMovie Render
121.20 seconds
96.11 seconds - - 26% Faster
Photoshop (Workflow)
38 seconds
36.81 seconds - - 3% Faster
Photoshop (Filters)
103.68 seconds
68.20 seconds - - 52% Faster
StuffIt Expand
52.69 seconds
46.56 seconds - - 13% Faster
MS Word
71.66 seconds
59.44 seconds - - 21% Faster
MS Excel
43.45 seconds
50.41 seconds - - 16% Slower
Notes

Processor performance based on CineBench 2003

Processor G4 Tuned Test based on AltiVec Fractal program

Graphics (Card) Test is based on CineBench 2003. In this type of image rendering, the graphics card takes the lead

Graphics (Processor) Test is based on CineBench 2003. In this type of image rendering, the processor takes the lead

Graphics Gaming (Card) Test is based on the game 4x4 EVO2 .. a racing game. All settings are at highest quality. This game is more graphics card dependent

Graphics Gaming (Processor) Test is based on the game Giants.. All settings are at highest quality. This game is more processor dependent ... will also make used of dual processors if present

The 'General Interface' test is based on Let1kWindowsBloom, which is freely available.

The Photoshop (Workflow) score is based on the BareFeats Photoshop Action Script, which you can download and run on your own machine, if you have Photoshop. Or download the Trial version from Adobe

Have questions about the performance of these machines?
For more detailed performance results see this page

Links To Further Information
Machine
Power Mac Dual G4/1 GHz
(#M8667LL/A )
Power Mac G5/1.6 GHz
(#M9020LL/A )
Reviews

MacComparisonZone: PowerMac Dual G4/1 GHz vs PowerMac Dual G5/2.0 GHz

SpeedZone - Towers Performance: Power Mac G4/800 To Dual G4/1.42

SpeedZone - From The Power Mac G4/800 To The Power Mac Dual G4/1.25 GHz-

CreativeMac
ComputerUser
BareFeats
BareFeats
BareFeats
PCMagazine
Macworld
Macworld
BareFeats
TechTV
MacCentral

MacComparisonZone: 12 Inch G4/1.33 GHz PowerBook vs Power Mac G5/1.6 GHz

MacComparisonZone: 17" iMac G4/1.25GHz vs Power Mac G5/1.6 GHz

MacComparisonZone: Dual Power Mac G4/1.25GHz vs Power Mac G5/1.6GH

A Performance & Feature Comparison Between The G4/1.25 GHz Tower And The G5/1.6 GHz Tower

SpeedZone: PowerBook A Desktop Replacement? ... G5 Power Mac Trounces G4/1.33 GHz PowerBook

SpeedZone: Is a 13% Performance Improvement Worth $400? ... 35 Performance Test Results For the G5/1.6 GHz & 1.8 GHz Towers

NewsFactor
BareFeats
Vunet
BareFeats
Macworld

MacUser

Macworld Lab

BareFeats
BareFeats
Vnunet
Chaosmint

Links to additional information
Price & Bundle Comparisons

Note

We receive a small commission on computers purchased using the links below. Though this adds no cost to your purchase price, it does help us defray the cost of running MacReviewZone and MacSpeedZone. Your support is appreciated! As always check your tax status at these merchants so that you don't get a nasty shock at checkout time.

For Latest up-to-date prices check the online Buyer's Guides


G4 Power Macs

PowerMac AGP Graphics G4/350  ... Original price: $1,599


None at this time ...
 

PowerMac AGP G4/400  ... Original price: $1,599


None at this time ...
 

PowerMac AGP G4/450 ... Original price: $3,500


None at this time ...
 

PowerMac AGP G4/500 ... Original price: $3,500


None at this time ...
 

PowerMac AGP G4 Upgraded to 800 MHz via Sonnet Encore upgrade ... Original price: $3,500


PowerMax - Used .... 90 day warranty .... Shipping $22. Tax: None ...Trade-in Program ... $888
 

PowerMac AGP G4 Upgraded to 1.4 GHz via Sonnet Encore upgrade ... Original price: $3,500


PowerMax - Used .... 90 day warranty .... Shipping $22. Tax: None ...Trade-in Program ... $1,474 to $1,479
 

PowerMac Gigabit G4/400 20 GB ... Original price: $1,600


None at this time ...

 

 

PowerMac Gigabit G4/450  ... Original price: $2,499


PowerMax - Used .... 90 day warranty .... Shipping $22. Tax: None ...Trade-in Program ... $588
 

PowerMac Gigabit DUAL G4/450  ... Original price: $2,499


PowerMax - Used .... 90 day warranty .... Shipping $22. Tax: None ...Trade-in Program ... $849
 

PowerMac Gigabit DUAL G4/500 640 MB, 40 GB drive, DVD-RAM ... Original price: $3,499

None This Week

 

PowerMac Gigabit G4 Upgraded to 1000 MHz via Sonnet Encore upgrade ... Original price: $3,500


None at this time ...
 

PowerMac Digital Audio G4/466 ... Original price: $1,699


None at this time ...
 

PowerMac Digital Audio Dual G4/533 ... Original price: $2,199


None at this time ...
 

PowerMac Digital Audio G4/733  ... Original price: $1,699


None at this time ...
 

PowerMac Digital Audio G4/800 ... Original price: $1,599


None at this time ...
 

PowerMac QuickSilver G4/867  ... Original price: $2,499


None at this time ...
 

Power Mac Dual G4/867 60 GB drive, Combo ... Original price: $1699


None at this time ...
 

PowerMac QuickSilver G4/933 60 GB drive, SuperDrive ... Original price: $2,299


None at this time ....

Power Mac G4/1 GHz 512 MB of RAM, 60 GB internal drive, internal Combo Drive ... Original price: $1,499


None at this time ...
 

PowerMac Dual G4/1 GHz 256 MB 80 GB, SuperDrive, 56k ... Original price: $2,499

 

PowerMac G4/1.25GHz 256/80/Superdrive #Z082

None at this time ...

 

Power Mac G4 1.25GHz /256MB/80GB/Combo/GigE/56K #M9145LL/A  ... Original price: $1,299


LA Computer Company - New ....1 year warranty .... Shipping $51. Tax: CA ...$1,499
 

PowerMac Dual G4/1.25 256 MB, 80 GB drive, Combo Drive, 56k modem


None at this time ...
 

PowerMac DUAL G4/1.25 GHz , 80 GB drive, SuperDrive 56k  ... Original price: $3,299


None at this time ...
 

Power Mac G4/1.25GhzDP 512/120/Superdrive/Radeon9000/56K #M8840LL/A  ... Original price: $3,299


Small Dog - Used .... 90 day warranty ... Shipping $41. Tax: VT ... $1,249 to $1,599
 

Power Mac G4 1.42 GHz DUAL/512MB/120GB/SuperDrive/GigE/56K #M8841LL/A  ... Original price: $2,699


None at this time ...
G5 Power Macs

PowerMac G5/1.6 GHz 256MB , 80 GB SuperDrive, #M9020LL/A  ... Original price: $1,799


ClubMac - Open Box (search for item M9020LL ) .... 90 day warranty .... Shipping Free. Tax: CA, TN, WI ... Bundled Extras .... $1,360
MacMall - Open Box (search for item M9020LL ) .... 90 day warranty .... Shipping Free. Tax: CA, TN, WI ... Bundled Extras .... $1,360
 

Power Mac G5 DUAL 1.8GHz 512MB/160GB/SuperDrive/GigE/56K #M9393LL/A  ... Original price:$2,499


PowerMax - Open Box .... 1 year warranty.... Shipping $37. Tax: None ...Trade-in Program ... Bundled Extras ... $2,149
PowerMax - New.... 1 year warranty.... Shipping $37. Tax: None ...Trade-in Program ... Bundled Extras ... $2,199
 

Power Mac G5 1.8GHz Dual Processor/256/80G/8xSuperDrive/PCI/GeFr5200  #M9454LL/A ... $1,999


None at this time
 

G5/2.0 GHz Dual Processor M9032LL/A ... Original price: $2,999


LA Computer Company - New ....3 year warranty .... Shipping $51. Tax: CA ... Bundled Extras ...$2,199 to $2,999
PowerMax - Refurbished ....one year warranty .... Shipping $25. Tax: None ...Trade-in Program ...$2,349 to $2,388
 

G5/2.0 GHz Dual Processor #M9455LL/A ... Original price: $2,499


PowerMax - Open Box .... 1 year warranty.... Shipping $37. Tax: None ...Trade-in Program ... Bundled Extras ... $2,449
 

G5/2.5 GHz Dual Processor #M9457LL/A ... Original price: $2,999


Apple Store - Refurbished .... one year warranty.... Shipping Free. Tax: All states with sales tax ... $2,799
 


 

Home Reviews Opinions & Articles Buyer's Guides MacSpeedZone

Copyright 1996-2007 by Cider Press Publishing LLC all rights reserved. MacReviewZone is not authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Apple Computer. Apple, the Apple logo, Macintosh, iPod, iBook, iMac, eMac, and PowerBook are registered trademarks of Apple Computer, Inc. Additional company and product names may be trademarks or registered trademarks and are hereby acknowledged.

| Top of page | Mail this page to a friend |